Shared 1st Place for IrSPEN 2023/24 Award for Overall Best Research Project, BSc Human Nutrition and Dietetics (join Trinity-TU Dublin) programme

 

Grace Fleming and Tara Howley have been awarded joint first place for the best undergraduate research project for the BSc Human Nutrition and Dietetics class of 2023-4

Grace Fleming

Biography:  I am a recent graduate from the joint degree BSc Human Nutrition and Dietetics in Technological University Dublin and Trinity College Dublin. I am honoured to have been awarded the IrSEPN Prize for ‘Joint Highest Overall Marks’ for my final year project, alongside one of my classmates. I am currently working as a CORU registered dietitian at Tallaght University Hospital, where I completed my final year placement. I am very excited to develop my skills and knowledge even further, through the learning and experiences that this position will provide me.

Research Summary:

My research project is titled ‘A Qualitative Analysis of the Breastfeeding Support Network in Ireland According to Healthcare Professionals and Members of Voluntary Organisations’, for which I was supervised by Dr. Liz O’ Sullivan.

Ireland has one of the lowest breastfeeding rates in the world. As Ireland does not have an infant and young child feeding in emergencies (IYCF-E) preparedness plan, Ireland’s infants are extremely vulnerable in emergencies, as formula feeding is associated with worse health outcomes. To ensure Ireland is better prepared for emergencies, increasing breastfeeding rates is essential. This study aimed to map out Ireland’s breastfeeding support network and understand how participants describe these supports, with the goal of understanding how breastfeeding rates can be improved.

From 30 pre-conducted semi-structured qualitative interviews among healthcare professionals (HCPs) and voluntary breastfeeding supporters, a list of the reported available breastfeeding supports was extracted, which was used to create a map of the available supports across the antenatal, perinatal and postnatal periods. Qualitative analysis of the interviews was conducted following Braun and Clarke’s ‘six-step Thematic Analysis Framework’.

The map highlights that although many breastfeeding supports are available, not all are easily accessible or universally available. Participants of the study reported many inequities which contribute to the difficulty in accessing these supports, such as geographical location and financial inequities. These inequities were also explored in the overarching themes of this study.

The first theme, ‘barriers to accessing appropriate breastfeeding support’, had 3 subthemes: ‘inappropriate advice and inconsistent messaging’, ‘challenges to progressing through the healthcare system’ and ‘We’re doing better, but we have loads we can do’. Overall this theme explores challenges faced by mothers when trying to access the required support, such as receiving mixed messages from different support providers and HCPs inappropriately recommending formula feeding. Many participants of the study described lack of time, staffing shortages and heavy workloads as one of the biggest barriers to providing mothers and families the support they need. Participants also commented on how Ireland has made ‘huge strides’ in terms of supports available, but also acknowledged that there are a lot of improvements still to be made.

The second theme, ‘breastfeeding support is disjointed and inequitable’, had 3 subthemes: ‘gaps in the system due to lack of long-term support and poor communication’, ‘uncertainty in referral pathways to more specialised supports’ and ‘consistent inequities in breastfeeding care’.  This theme captures the aspects of discontinuity in breastfeeding care that contribute to mothers not receiving adequate support. Some participants discussed how these gaps result in mothers having to navigate the system themselves. Many HCPs reported they are unsure of where to refer to mothers to for more specialised support as there are no clear referral pathways. Some participants acknowledged that their lack of education on breastfeeding may be a contributing factor to this. Consistent inequities, which are also highlighted in the map created, include geographical location, as different areas of the country have more supports than others, many having to access support privately rather than publicly and the cost factor associated with this, and those faced by minority groups such as the Travelling community.

The final theme, ‘We already have an emergency, it’s not planning for an emergency’, has 2 subthemes: ‘Ireland already has an infant feeding emergency’ and ‘In future emergencies, what is the role of voluntary organisations?’. This theme portrays how Ireland already has an infant feeding emergency due to the stigma around breastfeeding, the power of the formula industry and such high rates of formula feeding. It also discusses the different views of the participants about the role of voluntary organisations in future emergencies.

In conclusion, breastfeeding support in Ireland is inadequate, inequitable and lacks continuity. Lack of time and knowledge, inadequate staffing and heavy workloads are described as challenges women face to progress through the system and access support. Standardisation of and improved access to infant and young child feeding  (IYCF) training, strong communication, protected and dedicated IYCF posts, and clear referral pathways are needed to help improve breastfeeding support in Ireland. These improvements will ultimately make Ireland more resilient to protect breastfeeding in future emergencies

Tara Howley

Biography and Research Summary:

My research investigated more novel and liberalised approaches to the dietary management of irritable bowel syndrome given that the current second line management option, the low FODMAP diet, is complex and restrictive. Significant improvements and normalised stool type were identified in a group that follow a modified low FODMAP diet, involving the restriction of only the most prominent FODMAPs in one diet. Additionally, positive effects on symptoms of IBS were identified in a cohort that participated in a 14 week gut-directed hypnotherapy. I thoroughly enjoyed working on this project and hope to have it published in the near future. 
 
I am currently working in Mater Misercordiae University Hospital in the Care of the Older person.