Routine nutrition screening recommended for 58,000 receiving Home Care support
The introduction of nutritional screening as part of winter flu vaccination appointments for over 70s – has been recommended by nutrition experts.
In its 2022 Pre-Budget Submission the Irish Society for Clinical Nutrition and Metabolism (IrSPEN), supported by the Irish Nutrition and Dietetic Institute (INDI), has called for a pilot scheme integrating a five minute nutrition screening for over 70s as part of the winter jab appointment.
The submission also recommends that nutrition screening, performed by care staff once per quarter, be extended to the 58,000 people in receipt of home care support.
IrSPEN has estimated a cost of €150,000 to run a pilot nutrition scheme with winter flu vaccinations and €700,000 per annum to deliver quarterly nutrition screening to people receiving home care support. Most of the costs are for training staff.
IrSPEN Director Niamh Rice said the potential to identify patients before weight loss or changes to nutritional status is high, given that the prevalence of malnutrition is estimated to be at least 15% in over 70’s, and likely to be even higher in those presenting for flu vaccination.
“Screening, while waiting for vaccination or in the 15-minute wait post vaccination offers a low cost but highly cost-effective means of ensuring that patients at nutritional risk can be identified at a convenient point with the primary healthcare team, with minimal additional staffing cost other than training and initial piloting.”
“Also, the 58,000 older people receiving home care support are likely to be particularly vulnerable to malnutrition with an estimated prevalence of up to 30%. Integrating a five-minute nutritional screening every three months into their care, has the potential to avert costly hospital admissions, decrease healthcare usage and improve quality of life and independence.
“The cost of treating a malnourished patient is three times that of a nourished patient, and so it makes economic sense to identify any risk of malnutrition and treat it early. There is potential for lower healthcare utilisation, reduced burden on our GP services as well as improving the well-being and independence of many people.”
Improved early access to nutritional care for cancer patients
IrSPEN’s submission also called for improved early access to nutritional care for cancer patients – with a recommended investment costed at €1.7m per annum. This would fund 19 full-time dietitians to address gaps in dietetic services, and allow an estimated 9,000 assessments and follow-up reviews for chemotherapy patients (which would cover 25 – 30% of chemotherapy patients annually).
IrSPEN President and Oncology Surgeon Professor John Reynolds said: “The impact would be to reduce cancer waiting times overall, to reduce avoidable side effects of treatments and to ensure more effective interventions to protect nutritional status.”
Establish a Specialist Intestinal Rehabilitation Unit for adult patients
Thirdly the submission called for a Specialist Intestinal Rehabilitation Unit for adult patients in Ireland at a cost of €1.8m in 2022 and €4m per annum from 2023. Patients with Intestinal Failure (IF) are a highly complex patient group for which specialist care in a high-volume unit is critically important.
The submission recommends establishing a dedicated unit at St. James’s Hospital (linked to the national paediatric specialist unit at Our Lady’s Children’s Hospital) within a hub and spoke model, with units in Cork and Galway, based on successful models in UK and Europe.
An initial eight acute beds would serve a caseload of up to 50 patients with IF per year, which is equivalent to an estimated 50% of the needs based on new patients, allowing for a phased development over 3-5 years.
IrSPEN Director and Consultant Gastroenterologist, Dr. Cara Dunne, who provides care for IF patients transitioning from the specialist paediatric centre to adult services at St. James’s Hospital, says it is now urgent that the service is expanded to address the needs of adult patients.
“It’s now eight years since IrSPEN first issued its report highlighting our inability to manage these patients safely within non specialist centres. Each year, we estimate that there are at least 12 avoidable deaths that could be saved if they were treated within a specialist unit similar to that in the North of Ireland, the UK and the vast majority of European countries.”
Professor John Reynolds concluded by saying that using international comparisons, at least 12 avoidable deaths could be spared per year in Ireland as a result of specialist IF care.
The full budget submission is available at: https://irspen.ie/irspen-2022-pre-budget-submission-addressing-the-gaps-in-nutritional-care-for-patients-with-high-risk-conditions-in-community-settings/
Ronan Cavanagh, Cavanagh Communications: (086) 317 9731.